Ep 147 When Someone Shows No Interest in You: Why It Hurts
Unseen
Show notes
Show transcript
00:00:01: A few days ago, I went to a knitting event and ended up sitting next to a
00:00:04: woman I found genuinely interesting.
00:00:07: She had led a very interesting life, had been involved in all kinds of
00:00:11: activities, raised a large family, and was still remarkably active.
00:00:16: She had so many stories to tell, and I found myself thinking,
00:00:19: what an interesting person.
00:00:21: I'd really like to get to know her better.
00:00:24: But by the end of that afternoon, I was wondering whether this woman
00:00:27: was actually rather arrogant.
00:00:29: And what's interesting is that she hadn't really changed.
00:00:33: What had changed was the way I saw her.
00:00:37: Hi, and welcome to Lead Well!
00:00:43: I've been thinking about that encounter quite a bit since then, and the more I
00:00:47: thought about it, the more I realized that my reaction probably told me
00:00:52: more about myself than about her.
00:00:55: So that's what I'd like to explore with you today, because I suspect
00:01:00: I'm not the only one who has experienced something like this.
00:01:04: I really enjoy knitting, and recently I attended a knitting
00:01:07: event where about seven of us were sitting together around a table.
00:01:11: There was a woman sitting next to me who immediately caught my interest.
00:01:16: She was retired, but she certainly wasn't someone who had slowed down.
00:01:20: She'd been involved in all sorts of activities throughout her life,
00:01:24: and has raised a large family, and was still organizing things
00:01:27: and bringing people together.
00:01:29: She had a lot to tell us, and she did.
00:01:33: Actually, she talked about herself almost the entire time.
00:01:37: Now, I don't necessarily mind that.
00:01:40: I enjoy listening to people who have interesting experiences, particularly when
00:01:45: they've done things that are different from what I've done in my own life.
00:01:48: I find it fascinating to hear how people have made decisions, what they've
00:01:53: experienced, and what has shaped them.
00:01:56: So initially, I was quite happy to listen.
00:01:59: But as the afternoon went on, I noticed something.
00:02:02: She wasn't asking any questions, not about me, not about the other
00:02:06: people sitting at the table.
00:02:08: Apart from the knitting itself, there didn't seem to be much
00:02:11: curiosity about anyone else's life.
00:02:14: And I noticed that, but at the time it didn't particularly bother me.
00:02:18: I was still interested in her.
00:02:21: In fact, I had already started thinking that she might be someone
00:02:24: I'd like to stay in contact with.
00:02:26: She seemed to have an active social life.
00:02:28: She was involved in interesting activities, and I thought perhaps
00:02:32: we might have things in common.
00:02:34: Perhaps we'd meet again.
00:02:35: Perhaps we'd have interesting conversations.
00:02:38: Perhaps I'd even get to know other people through her.
00:02:42: You know how sometimes you meet someone and immediately think, "This
00:02:46: could be an interesting connection"?
00:02:49: That was how I felt.
00:02:51: So toward the end of our meeting, I told her that I'd like to stay in touch,
00:02:54: and I handed her my business card.
00:02:57: She looked at it and said something along the lines of, "Oh, another
00:03:01: coach." And it was the way she said it.
00:03:05: Of course, I can't reproduce her exact tone, and I don't know what she intended,
00:03:10: but to me it sounded rather dismissive.
00:03:14: She did give me her card in return, but I didn't get the
00:03:16: impression that she was particularly interested in staying in contact.
00:03:21: And I was disappointed, more disappointed than I would have expected, considering
00:03:27: I'd only just met this woman.
00:03:29: What happened next is what I find so interesting.
00:03:33: I started looking at her differently.
00:03:35: All those stories she told us about her life, her activities,
00:03:40: her achievements, suddenly I wasn't hearing them as the stories of an
00:03:44: interesting, accomplished woman anymore.
00:03:47: I started wondering whether she was rather full of herself.
00:03:51: Was she really so confident, or was she arrogant?
00:03:56: Was she simply proud of what she'd achieved, or did she think she was
00:04:01: more important than everyone else?
00:04:03: Why did she have to talk about herself all the time?
00:04:06: Why wasn't she interested in anyone else?
00:04:09: And then I caught myself.
00:04:13: Hang on a minute.
00:04:15: I'd been listening to this woman for quite some time.
00:04:18: I'd found her interesting.
00:04:19: I'd admire how active and engaged she was.
00:04:23: And now, after one rather dismissive comment, I was interpreting everything
00:04:28: she'd said in a completely different way.
00:04:31: Her behavior during the afternoon hadn't changed, but my interpretation
00:04:35: of it had, and I began to wonder why.
00:04:41: Now, there is a well-known phenomenon in psychology called
00:04:44: the fundamental attribution error.
00:04:46: In simple terms, we tend to explain other people's behavior by referring to their
00:04:50: personality rather than considering what might be going on in their situation.
00:04:55: Someone is unfriendly, and we conclude they're an unfriendly person.
00:04:59: Someone talks a lot about themselves, and we decide they're self-centered.
00:05:04: Of course, sometimes our impressions may be accurate, but we often have far
00:05:09: less information than we think we do.
00:05:12: I had no idea what was happening in this woman's life.
00:05:15: Perhaps she was simply excited to have an audience.
00:05:18: Perhaps she was used to telling stories.
00:05:20: Perhaps she'd had a difficult week, or perhaps she simply wasn't interested in
00:05:24: making new acquaintances that afternoon.
00:05:27: I don't know.
00:05:29: But I had started making judgments about her character based on a
00:05:34: relatively short encounter, and that made me curious about my own reaction.
00:05:41: The first question I asked myself was whether this actually was about my ego.
00:05:47: Because if I'm very honest, I think there was a part of me
00:05:50: that wanted her to recognize that I had an interesting life too.
00:05:54: I mean, I've done quite a few different things.
00:05:56: I've worked internationally, held senior leadership positions, traveled
00:06:00: extensively, and eventually changed my professional direction completely.
00:06:05: I've had experiences I'm proud of, and here I was, sitting at a knitting table
00:06:11: listening to someone talking about all the things she'd accomplished, while she
00:06:15: apparently had absolutely no interest in finding out anything about me.
00:06:21: Was that what was bothering me?
00:06:24: Did I want her to recognize that I was an interesting person too?
00:06:29: And that led me to an even more uncomfortable question.
00:06:32: Do I always need to be seen as intelligent,
00:06:36: accomplished, or knowledgeable?
00:06:39: Do I perhaps need to be the smartest person in the room?
00:06:44: Now, that's not a particularly flattering question to ask yourself.
00:06:48: But I think it's worth asking,
00:06:50: especially when you've spent much of your professional life
00:06:53: being valued for your expertise.
00:06:56: You get used to people asking for your opinion.
00:06:59: You get used to being listened to.
00:07:00: You get used to the fact that your experience and knowledge matter.
00:07:05: And perhaps without really noticing, you begin to expect a certain amount of
00:07:09: recognition, not necessarily admiration, but at least acknowledgement that you
00:07:15: have something interesting to contribute.
00:07:18: And what happens when you walk into a room where nobody knows who you are or
00:07:22: you've done or what you're capable of?
00:07:25: Are you comfortable simply being another person at the table?
00:07:30: Or do you feel a little urge to make sure people know there's more to you?
00:07:36: I think that's a question worth exploring, particularly for
00:07:39: those of us who have spent years building a professional identity.
00:07:44: And yes, when I thought about it, I had to acknowledge that I probably
00:07:48: did want this woman and the others on the table to recognize that
00:07:52: I had an interesting background.
00:07:55: But something about that explanation still didn't feel quite right, because
00:07:59: I don't generally need everyone I meet to be impressed by me, and I certainly
00:08:05: don't go to a knitting event to talk about my professional achievements.
00:08:09: So why did it matter so much in this particular situation?
00:08:15: I kept thinking about it, and eventually I realized that there was something
00:08:20: else behind my disappointment.
00:08:22: Something that felt much more important than recognition.
00:08:27: I had wanted to connect with this woman.
00:08:31: That's really what it was all about.
00:08:33: I found her interesting.
00:08:35: I liked the fact that she was active, curious about life,
00:08:39: involved in different things.
00:08:40: She seemed like someone with whom I might have interesting conversations, and I
00:08:45: wanted her to find me interesting, too.
00:08:49: Not so that she would admire me, but so that she might want to get to know me.
00:08:54: I wanted her to see that there could be something worth exploring between us.
00:08:59: That perhaps we had things in common or could learn something from each other,
00:09:03: or simply enjoy spending time together.
00:09:06: And suddenly, the whole business card incident made much more sense.
00:09:11: When I handed her my card, I wasn't really trying to promote my coaching business.
00:09:17: I was making an invitation.
00:09:18: I was saying, in effect, " I'd like to stay in touch with you."
00:09:23: And what I perceived in her response was that she wasn't particularly interested.
00:09:29: That was what hurt.
00:09:32: Not so much that she didn't recognize my achievements.
00:09:36: But that she didn't seem interested in me as a person.
00:09:40: And I think that distinction is important because wanting recognition and wanting
00:09:45: connection are not the same thing, although they can certainly overlap.
00:09:52: Sometimes we want people to find us interesting because
00:09:55: we want their admiration.
00:09:57: But sometimes we want people to find us interesting because we
00:10:00: want a relationship with them.
00:10:02: We want to be included.
00:10:04: We want to belong.
00:10:05: We want to discover common ground.
00:10:08: And when that interest isn't reciprocated , we can feel rejected,
00:10:12: even when we've only just met someone.
00:10:16: I find it quite remarkable how quickly we can develop expectations about
00:10:20: people we've only just encountered.
00:10:23: Within a relatively short time, I'd already imagined the possibility
00:10:27: of a friendship or at least an interesting acquaintance.
00:10:31: I pictured future conversations, perhaps meeting again, perhaps getting
00:10:35: to know other people through her.
00:10:38: None of that had actually happened.
00:10:41: It was simply a possibility I'd created in my mind.
00:10:44: And yet, when I felt that possibility disappearing, I was disappointed.
00:10:50: There is a basic human need behind this, of course.
00:10:54: We want connection.
00:10:55: We want to feel that other people are interested in us,
00:10:59: that we're worth getting to know.
00:11:02: Psychologists have studied this extensively.
00:11:05: One influential perspective proposed by Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary
00:11:10: is that the need to belong is a fundamental human motivation.
00:11:15: We're social beings, and relationships matter to us.
00:11:19: Being noticed, listened to, and shown genuine curiosity can be part of
00:11:24: how we experience that connection.
00:11:26: Think about a conversation where someone asks you a question and then really
00:11:30: listens to your answer, not because they're waiting for their turn to speak,
00:11:35: but because they actually want to know.
00:11:38: How different does that feel from a conversation where someone talks
00:11:41: continuously about themselves?
00:11:43: Now, I don't want to suggest that people who talk a lot
00:11:46: about themselves are necessarily arrogant or uninterested in others.
00:11:51: Some people are nervous.
00:11:53: Some get carried away by their enthusiasm.
00:11:55: Some are simply more comfortable talking than asking questions.
00:11:59: And some people genuinely aren't looking for new connections,
00:12:03: which is perfectly fine.
00:12:06: Just because I find someone interesting doesn't mean they're obliged to
00:12:09: find me interesting in return.
00:12:12: But knowing that intellectually doesn't mean I can't feel disappointed.
00:12:17: And perhaps that's where things get complicated.
00:12:21: Because disappointment is one thing, turning that disappointment
00:12:25: into a judgment about the other person's character is something else.
00:12:31: Looking back, I think that's exactly what happened.
00:12:34: I was interested in this woman.
00:12:35: I hoped she would be interested in me.
00:12:38: When I didn't feel that interest coming back, I was hurt.
00:12:42: And instead of simply acknowledging that disappointment, I started
00:12:46: questioning whether she was arrogant.
00:12:50: Now, perhaps she was, I still don't know.
00:12:53: But I do know that my judgment was influenced by what I had hoped to
00:12:57: receive from her, and I think that's worth paying attention to, because
00:13:03: we do this in so many situations.
00:13:06: We meet someone and hope for a friendly conversation.
00:13:10: When they're distant, we conclude they're unfriendly.
00:13:12: We share an idea with a colleague and hope for enthusiasm.
00:13:16: When they don't respond as we expected, we think they're dismissive.
00:13:21: We offer someone a connection and hope they'll welcome it.
00:13:24: When they don't, we start questioning their attitude.
00:13:28: Sometimes those judgments may be justified, but sometimes we're reacting as
00:13:33: much to our own disappointed expectations as to the other person's behavior, and
00:13:40: that distinction isn't always obvious.
00:13:43: I think it becomes particularly relevant in leadership, where we constantly
00:13:48: interpret other people's reactions.
00:13:52: A team member doesn't seem interested in our ideas.
00:13:55: Is that resistance, disrespect, a lack of engagement, or did we perhaps
00:14:00: expect enthusiasm and feel personally disappointed when we didn't receive it?
00:14:06: An employee doesn't ask for our advice.
00:14:08: Do we interpret that as independence, or does some part of us feel that
00:14:12: our expertise isn't being valued?
00:14:16: These are subtle things, but they can influence how we respond to people.
00:14:21: And when you think about the interaction with our animals, it's exactly the same.
00:14:27: We have expectations, they respond differently, and
00:14:32: already we're judging them.
00:14:35: And if we're not aware of our own expectations, we may end up reacting
00:14:39: to a story we've created rather than to what's actually happening.
00:14:44: I started this whole reflection by asking myself whether that
00:14:47: woman was confident or arrogant.
00:14:50: And I still think it's an interesting question because there is nothing wrong
00:14:54: with being proud of what you've achieved.
00:14:57: I certainly don't think we should make ourselves smaller, particularly as women,
00:15:02: just to avoid appearing too confident.
00:15:05: And I don't believe that talking about your accomplishments
00:15:08: automatically makes you arrogant.
00:15:11: But I do think there is a relational dimension to how confidence comes across.
00:15:16: It's one thing to be aware of your own strength and achievements,
00:15:20: and it's another to leave no room for anyone else's experiences.
00:15:24: And perhaps that's one reason why curiosity matters so much.
00:15:29: When we're genuinely interested in other people, we're communicating something
00:15:33: beyond the actual questions we ask.
00:15:37: We're communicating that their experiences matter, too.
00:15:42: That we don't need to compete for importance, that there is room for more
00:15:46: than one interesting person at a table.
00:15:49: Of course, that doesn't mean we need to ask questions constantly
00:15:52: or that every conversation needs to be perfectly balanced.
00:15:56: But I think most of us recognize the difference between a conversation
00:16:00: where someone is sharing their life with us and one where we feel like
00:16:04: we're simply providing an audience.
00:16:07: And there's another question I want to ask myself.
00:16:11: How curious was I really about this woman once I started feeling disappointed?
00:16:17: Did I continue listening with the same openness, or did I
00:16:21: begin looking for evidence that confirmed my growing irritation?
00:16:26: Because if I want genuine connection, that curiosity has to go both ways.
00:16:32: And perhaps I wasn't quite as open toward the end of our conversation
00:16:36: as I had been at the beginning.
00:16:37: I don't know, but it's something worth considering.
00:16:41: So here I am reflecting on an ordinary afternoon at a knitting event.
00:16:47: I met a woman I found fascinating.
00:16:50: I hoped we might stay in contact.
00:16:52: I felt disappointed when her response didn't seem particularly
00:16:56: welcoming, and I went home wondering whether she was arrogant.
00:17:02: But the more I thought about it, the more I realized that I had learned very
00:17:06: little about whether she was arrogant.
00:17:08: What I had learned was something about myself.
00:17:12: About my desire to be seen, about the fact that I sometimes want people to
00:17:16: recognize that I have an interesting life and something to contribute.
00:17:21: And more importantly, about how closely that desire can be connected to my
00:17:25: wish for meaningful relationships.
00:17:28: I wanted her to find me interesting because I wanted
00:17:31: her to want to get to know me.
00:17:34: And when that didn't happen, I interpreted her behavior through my disappointment.
00:17:40: I still think her comment was dismissive, at least that's how it came across to me.
00:17:45: And understanding my own reaction doesn't mean I have
00:17:48: to pretend it didn't bother me.
00:17:51: But it does help me separate what she actually did from the meaning I gave it.
00:17:56: I don't know whether she'll ever contact me.
00:17:59: I have her card, and perhaps at some point we'll meet again, or perhaps not.
00:18:04: Either way, I think this encounter has already given me something valuable.
00:18:09: Because the next time I notice myself judging someone rather
00:18:12: quickly, particularly when they've irritated or disappointed me, I
00:18:17: want to ask myself two questions: What did this person actually do?
00:18:23: And what was I hoping to receive from them?
00:18:27: Was I hoping for appreciation, recognition, respect, agreement,
00:18:33: or perhaps simply a little curiosity and a chance to connect?
00:18:37: I suspect the answers might surprise me, and I'm curious whether you've
00:18:42: experienced something similar.
00:18:44: Have you ever met someone you really wanted to get to know,
00:18:48: only to discover that the interest didn't seem to be mutual?
00:18:53: And did you notice how that disappointment affected the way you saw them?
00:18:59: I'd love to hear your thoughts about that.
00:19:02: Until next time, take good care of yourself, stay curious, and Lead Well!
00:19:09: This was Lead Well!
00:19:10: Now what is the one thing that you're taking away from this episode?
00:19:14: Please share in the comments below and do share the podcast with your friends
00:19:18: and family, but only if you like it.
New comment