Ep 147 When Someone Shows No Interest in You: Why It Hurts

Unseen

Show notes

An ordinary conversation at a knitting event raises a question: did the other person’s behaviour change, or did disappointment change how Christine saw her? In this episode: - How the fundamental attribution error can shape judgments about other people. - The difference between wanting recognition and wanting a meaningful connection. - How professional identity can influence our expectations of being heard and valued. - Why a team member’s response may not mean resistance, disrespect or disengagement. - The role of mutual curiosity in making room for other people’s experiences. Two questions to reflect on when someone irritates or disappoints you: - What did this person actually do? - What was I hoping to receive from them? Understanding your reaction doesn’t mean dismissing your disappointment. It can help you distinguish someone’s actions from the meaning you gave them.

Show transcript

00:00:01: A few days ago, I went to a knitting event and ended up sitting next to a

00:00:04: woman I found genuinely interesting.

00:00:07: She had led a very interesting life, had been involved in all kinds of

00:00:11: activities, raised a large family, and was still remarkably active.

00:00:16: She had so many stories to tell, and I found myself thinking,

00:00:19: what an interesting person.

00:00:21: I'd really like to get to know her better.

00:00:24: But by the end of that afternoon, I was wondering whether this woman

00:00:27: was actually rather arrogant.

00:00:29: And what's interesting is that she hadn't really changed.

00:00:33: What had changed was the way I saw her.

00:00:37: Hi, and welcome to Lead Well!

00:00:43: I've been thinking about that encounter quite a bit since then, and the more I

00:00:47: thought about it, the more I realized that my reaction probably told me

00:00:52: more about myself than about her.

00:00:55: So that's what I'd like to explore with you today, because I suspect

00:01:00: I'm not the only one who has experienced something like this.

00:01:04: I really enjoy knitting, and recently I attended a knitting

00:01:07: event where about seven of us were sitting together around a table.

00:01:11: There was a woman sitting next to me who immediately caught my interest.

00:01:16: She was retired, but she certainly wasn't someone who had slowed down.

00:01:20: She'd been involved in all sorts of activities throughout her life,

00:01:24: and has raised a large family, and was still organizing things

00:01:27: and bringing people together.

00:01:29: She had a lot to tell us, and she did.

00:01:33: Actually, she talked about herself almost the entire time.

00:01:37: Now, I don't necessarily mind that.

00:01:40: I enjoy listening to people who have interesting experiences, particularly when

00:01:45: they've done things that are different from what I've done in my own life.

00:01:48: I find it fascinating to hear how people have made decisions, what they've

00:01:53: experienced, and what has shaped them.

00:01:56: So initially, I was quite happy to listen.

00:01:59: But as the afternoon went on, I noticed something.

00:02:02: She wasn't asking any questions, not about me, not about the other

00:02:06: people sitting at the table.

00:02:08: Apart from the knitting itself, there didn't seem to be much

00:02:11: curiosity about anyone else's life.

00:02:14: And I noticed that, but at the time it didn't particularly bother me.

00:02:18: I was still interested in her.

00:02:21: In fact, I had already started thinking that she might be someone

00:02:24: I'd like to stay in contact with.

00:02:26: She seemed to have an active social life.

00:02:28: She was involved in interesting activities, and I thought perhaps

00:02:32: we might have things in common.

00:02:34: Perhaps we'd meet again.

00:02:35: Perhaps we'd have interesting conversations.

00:02:38: Perhaps I'd even get to know other people through her.

00:02:42: You know how sometimes you meet someone and immediately think, "This

00:02:46: could be an interesting connection"?

00:02:49: That was how I felt.

00:02:51: So toward the end of our meeting, I told her that I'd like to stay in touch,

00:02:54: and I handed her my business card.

00:02:57: She looked at it and said something along the lines of, "Oh, another

00:03:01: coach." And it was the way she said it.

00:03:05: Of course, I can't reproduce her exact tone, and I don't know what she intended,

00:03:10: but to me it sounded rather dismissive.

00:03:14: She did give me her card in return, but I didn't get the

00:03:16: impression that she was particularly interested in staying in contact.

00:03:21: And I was disappointed, more disappointed than I would have expected, considering

00:03:27: I'd only just met this woman.

00:03:29: What happened next is what I find so interesting.

00:03:33: I started looking at her differently.

00:03:35: All those stories she told us about her life, her activities,

00:03:40: her achievements, suddenly I wasn't hearing them as the stories of an

00:03:44: interesting, accomplished woman anymore.

00:03:47: I started wondering whether she was rather full of herself.

00:03:51: Was she really so confident, or was she arrogant?

00:03:56: Was she simply proud of what she'd achieved, or did she think she was

00:04:01: more important than everyone else?

00:04:03: Why did she have to talk about herself all the time?

00:04:06: Why wasn't she interested in anyone else?

00:04:09: And then I caught myself.

00:04:13: Hang on a minute.

00:04:15: I'd been listening to this woman for quite some time.

00:04:18: I'd found her interesting.

00:04:19: I'd admire how active and engaged she was.

00:04:23: And now, after one rather dismissive comment, I was interpreting everything

00:04:28: she'd said in a completely different way.

00:04:31: Her behavior during the afternoon hadn't changed, but my interpretation

00:04:35: of it had, and I began to wonder why.

00:04:41: Now, there is a well-known phenomenon in psychology called

00:04:44: the fundamental attribution error.

00:04:46: In simple terms, we tend to explain other people's behavior by referring to their

00:04:50: personality rather than considering what might be going on in their situation.

00:04:55: Someone is unfriendly, and we conclude they're an unfriendly person.

00:04:59: Someone talks a lot about themselves, and we decide they're self-centered.

00:05:04: Of course, sometimes our impressions may be accurate, but we often have far

00:05:09: less information than we think we do.

00:05:12: I had no idea what was happening in this woman's life.

00:05:15: Perhaps she was simply excited to have an audience.

00:05:18: Perhaps she was used to telling stories.

00:05:20: Perhaps she'd had a difficult week, or perhaps she simply wasn't interested in

00:05:24: making new acquaintances that afternoon.

00:05:27: I don't know.

00:05:29: But I had started making judgments about her character based on a

00:05:34: relatively short encounter, and that made me curious about my own reaction.

00:05:41: The first question I asked myself was whether this actually was about my ego.

00:05:47: Because if I'm very honest, I think there was a part of me

00:05:50: that wanted her to recognize that I had an interesting life too.

00:05:54: I mean, I've done quite a few different things.

00:05:56: I've worked internationally, held senior leadership positions, traveled

00:06:00: extensively, and eventually changed my professional direction completely.

00:06:05: I've had experiences I'm proud of, and here I was, sitting at a knitting table

00:06:11: listening to someone talking about all the things she'd accomplished, while she

00:06:15: apparently had absolutely no interest in finding out anything about me.

00:06:21: Was that what was bothering me?

00:06:24: Did I want her to recognize that I was an interesting person too?

00:06:29: And that led me to an even more uncomfortable question.

00:06:32: Do I always need to be seen as intelligent,

00:06:36: accomplished, or knowledgeable?

00:06:39: Do I perhaps need to be the smartest person in the room?

00:06:44: Now, that's not a particularly flattering question to ask yourself.

00:06:48: But I think it's worth asking,

00:06:50: especially when you've spent much of your professional life

00:06:53: being valued for your expertise.

00:06:56: You get used to people asking for your opinion.

00:06:59: You get used to being listened to.

00:07:00: You get used to the fact that your experience and knowledge matter.

00:07:05: And perhaps without really noticing, you begin to expect a certain amount of

00:07:09: recognition, not necessarily admiration, but at least acknowledgement that you

00:07:15: have something interesting to contribute.

00:07:18: And what happens when you walk into a room where nobody knows who you are or

00:07:22: you've done or what you're capable of?

00:07:25: Are you comfortable simply being another person at the table?

00:07:30: Or do you feel a little urge to make sure people know there's more to you?

00:07:36: I think that's a question worth exploring, particularly for

00:07:39: those of us who have spent years building a professional identity.

00:07:44: And yes, when I thought about it, I had to acknowledge that I probably

00:07:48: did want this woman and the others on the table to recognize that

00:07:52: I had an interesting background.

00:07:55: But something about that explanation still didn't feel quite right, because

00:07:59: I don't generally need everyone I meet to be impressed by me, and I certainly

00:08:05: don't go to a knitting event to talk about my professional achievements.

00:08:09: So why did it matter so much in this particular situation?

00:08:15: I kept thinking about it, and eventually I realized that there was something

00:08:20: else behind my disappointment.

00:08:22: Something that felt much more important than recognition.

00:08:27: I had wanted to connect with this woman.

00:08:31: That's really what it was all about.

00:08:33: I found her interesting.

00:08:35: I liked the fact that she was active, curious about life,

00:08:39: involved in different things.

00:08:40: She seemed like someone with whom I might have interesting conversations, and I

00:08:45: wanted her to find me interesting, too.

00:08:49: Not so that she would admire me, but so that she might want to get to know me.

00:08:54: I wanted her to see that there could be something worth exploring between us.

00:08:59: That perhaps we had things in common or could learn something from each other,

00:09:03: or simply enjoy spending time together.

00:09:06: And suddenly, the whole business card incident made much more sense.

00:09:11: When I handed her my card, I wasn't really trying to promote my coaching business.

00:09:17: I was making an invitation.

00:09:18: I was saying, in effect, " I'd like to stay in touch with you."

00:09:23: And what I perceived in her response was that she wasn't particularly interested.

00:09:29: That was what hurt.

00:09:32: Not so much that she didn't recognize my achievements.

00:09:36: But that she didn't seem interested in me as a person.

00:09:40: And I think that distinction is important because wanting recognition and wanting

00:09:45: connection are not the same thing, although they can certainly overlap.

00:09:52: Sometimes we want people to find us interesting because

00:09:55: we want their admiration.

00:09:57: But sometimes we want people to find us interesting because we

00:10:00: want a relationship with them.

00:10:02: We want to be included.

00:10:04: We want to belong.

00:10:05: We want to discover common ground.

00:10:08: And when that interest isn't reciprocated , we can feel rejected,

00:10:12: even when we've only just met someone.

00:10:16: I find it quite remarkable how quickly we can develop expectations about

00:10:20: people we've only just encountered.

00:10:23: Within a relatively short time, I'd already imagined the possibility

00:10:27: of a friendship or at least an interesting acquaintance.

00:10:31: I pictured future conversations, perhaps meeting again, perhaps getting

00:10:35: to know other people through her.

00:10:38: None of that had actually happened.

00:10:41: It was simply a possibility I'd created in my mind.

00:10:44: And yet, when I felt that possibility disappearing, I was disappointed.

00:10:50: There is a basic human need behind this, of course.

00:10:54: We want connection.

00:10:55: We want to feel that other people are interested in us,

00:10:59: that we're worth getting to know.

00:11:02: Psychologists have studied this extensively.

00:11:05: One influential perspective proposed by Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary

00:11:10: is that the need to belong is a fundamental human motivation.

00:11:15: We're social beings, and relationships matter to us.

00:11:19: Being noticed, listened to, and shown genuine curiosity can be part of

00:11:24: how we experience that connection.

00:11:26: Think about a conversation where someone asks you a question and then really

00:11:30: listens to your answer, not because they're waiting for their turn to speak,

00:11:35: but because they actually want to know.

00:11:38: How different does that feel from a conversation where someone talks

00:11:41: continuously about themselves?

00:11:43: Now, I don't want to suggest that people who talk a lot

00:11:46: about themselves are necessarily arrogant or uninterested in others.

00:11:51: Some people are nervous.

00:11:53: Some get carried away by their enthusiasm.

00:11:55: Some are simply more comfortable talking than asking questions.

00:11:59: And some people genuinely aren't looking for new connections,

00:12:03: which is perfectly fine.

00:12:06: Just because I find someone interesting doesn't mean they're obliged to

00:12:09: find me interesting in return.

00:12:12: But knowing that intellectually doesn't mean I can't feel disappointed.

00:12:17: And perhaps that's where things get complicated.

00:12:21: Because disappointment is one thing, turning that disappointment

00:12:25: into a judgment about the other person's character is something else.

00:12:31: Looking back, I think that's exactly what happened.

00:12:34: I was interested in this woman.

00:12:35: I hoped she would be interested in me.

00:12:38: When I didn't feel that interest coming back, I was hurt.

00:12:42: And instead of simply acknowledging that disappointment, I started

00:12:46: questioning whether she was arrogant.

00:12:50: Now, perhaps she was, I still don't know.

00:12:53: But I do know that my judgment was influenced by what I had hoped to

00:12:57: receive from her, and I think that's worth paying attention to, because

00:13:03: we do this in so many situations.

00:13:06: We meet someone and hope for a friendly conversation.

00:13:10: When they're distant, we conclude they're unfriendly.

00:13:12: We share an idea with a colleague and hope for enthusiasm.

00:13:16: When they don't respond as we expected, we think they're dismissive.

00:13:21: We offer someone a connection and hope they'll welcome it.

00:13:24: When they don't, we start questioning their attitude.

00:13:28: Sometimes those judgments may be justified, but sometimes we're reacting as

00:13:33: much to our own disappointed expectations as to the other person's behavior, and

00:13:40: that distinction isn't always obvious.

00:13:43: I think it becomes particularly relevant in leadership, where we constantly

00:13:48: interpret other people's reactions.

00:13:52: A team member doesn't seem interested in our ideas.

00:13:55: Is that resistance, disrespect, a lack of engagement, or did we perhaps

00:14:00: expect enthusiasm and feel personally disappointed when we didn't receive it?

00:14:06: An employee doesn't ask for our advice.

00:14:08: Do we interpret that as independence, or does some part of us feel that

00:14:12: our expertise isn't being valued?

00:14:16: These are subtle things, but they can influence how we respond to people.

00:14:21: And when you think about the interaction with our animals, it's exactly the same.

00:14:27: We have expectations, they respond differently, and

00:14:32: already we're judging them.

00:14:35: And if we're not aware of our own expectations, we may end up reacting

00:14:39: to a story we've created rather than to what's actually happening.

00:14:44: I started this whole reflection by asking myself whether that

00:14:47: woman was confident or arrogant.

00:14:50: And I still think it's an interesting question because there is nothing wrong

00:14:54: with being proud of what you've achieved.

00:14:57: I certainly don't think we should make ourselves smaller, particularly as women,

00:15:02: just to avoid appearing too confident.

00:15:05: And I don't believe that talking about your accomplishments

00:15:08: automatically makes you arrogant.

00:15:11: But I do think there is a relational dimension to how confidence comes across.

00:15:16: It's one thing to be aware of your own strength and achievements,

00:15:20: and it's another to leave no room for anyone else's experiences.

00:15:24: And perhaps that's one reason why curiosity matters so much.

00:15:29: When we're genuinely interested in other people, we're communicating something

00:15:33: beyond the actual questions we ask.

00:15:37: We're communicating that their experiences matter, too.

00:15:42: That we don't need to compete for importance, that there is room for more

00:15:46: than one interesting person at a table.

00:15:49: Of course, that doesn't mean we need to ask questions constantly

00:15:52: or that every conversation needs to be perfectly balanced.

00:15:56: But I think most of us recognize the difference between a conversation

00:16:00: where someone is sharing their life with us and one where we feel like

00:16:04: we're simply providing an audience.

00:16:07: And there's another question I want to ask myself.

00:16:11: How curious was I really about this woman once I started feeling disappointed?

00:16:17: Did I continue listening with the same openness, or did I

00:16:21: begin looking for evidence that confirmed my growing irritation?

00:16:26: Because if I want genuine connection, that curiosity has to go both ways.

00:16:32: And perhaps I wasn't quite as open toward the end of our conversation

00:16:36: as I had been at the beginning.

00:16:37: I don't know, but it's something worth considering.

00:16:41: So here I am reflecting on an ordinary afternoon at a knitting event.

00:16:47: I met a woman I found fascinating.

00:16:50: I hoped we might stay in contact.

00:16:52: I felt disappointed when her response didn't seem particularly

00:16:56: welcoming, and I went home wondering whether she was arrogant.

00:17:02: But the more I thought about it, the more I realized that I had learned very

00:17:06: little about whether she was arrogant.

00:17:08: What I had learned was something about myself.

00:17:12: About my desire to be seen, about the fact that I sometimes want people to

00:17:16: recognize that I have an interesting life and something to contribute.

00:17:21: And more importantly, about how closely that desire can be connected to my

00:17:25: wish for meaningful relationships.

00:17:28: I wanted her to find me interesting because I wanted

00:17:31: her to want to get to know me.

00:17:34: And when that didn't happen, I interpreted her behavior through my disappointment.

00:17:40: I still think her comment was dismissive, at least that's how it came across to me.

00:17:45: And understanding my own reaction doesn't mean I have

00:17:48: to pretend it didn't bother me.

00:17:51: But it does help me separate what she actually did from the meaning I gave it.

00:17:56: I don't know whether she'll ever contact me.

00:17:59: I have her card, and perhaps at some point we'll meet again, or perhaps not.

00:18:04: Either way, I think this encounter has already given me something valuable.

00:18:09: Because the next time I notice myself judging someone rather

00:18:12: quickly, particularly when they've irritated or disappointed me, I

00:18:17: want to ask myself two questions: What did this person actually do?

00:18:23: And what was I hoping to receive from them?

00:18:27: Was I hoping for appreciation, recognition, respect, agreement,

00:18:33: or perhaps simply a little curiosity and a chance to connect?

00:18:37: I suspect the answers might surprise me, and I'm curious whether you've

00:18:42: experienced something similar.

00:18:44: Have you ever met someone you really wanted to get to know,

00:18:48: only to discover that the interest didn't seem to be mutual?

00:18:53: And did you notice how that disappointment affected the way you saw them?

00:18:59: I'd love to hear your thoughts about that.

00:19:02: Until next time, take good care of yourself, stay curious, and Lead Well!

00:19:09: This was Lead Well!

00:19:10: Now what is the one thing that you're taking away from this episode?

00:19:14: Please share in the comments below and do share the podcast with your friends

00:19:18: and family, but only if you like it.

New comment

Your name or nickname, will be shown publicly
At least 10 characters long
By submitting your comment you agree that the content of the field "Name or nickname" will be stored and shown publicly next to your comment. Using your real name is optional.